Did Subjectivity Play a Role in CDO Credit Ratings?
- Author(s): JOHN M. GRIFFIN, DRAGON YONGJUN TANG
- Published: Jul 19, 2012
- Pages: 1293-1328
- DOI: 10.1111/j.1540-6261.2012.01748.x
Analyzing 916 collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), we find that a top credit rating agency frequently made positive adjustments beyond its main model that amounted to increasingly larger AAA tranche sizes. These adjustments are difficult to explain by likely determinants, but exhibit a clear pattern: CDOs with smaller model‐implied AAA sizes receive larger adjustments. CDOs with larger adjustments experience more severe subsequent downgrading. Additionally, prior to April 2007, 91.2% of AAA‐rated CDOs only comply with the credit rating agency's own AA default rate standard. Accounting for adjustments and the criterion deviation indicates that on average AAA tranches were structured to BBB support levels.